Is this Fireplace Safe?

Sonic42
  • Is this Fireplace Safe? Sonic42

    I built a wood house that I'm rather proud of. I've built a fireplace that seem safe, but I don't want to risk burning my house down. I've seen plenty of tutorials online for making safe fireplaces, but most of them are more than 1 year old, and possibly obsolete. I tried reading the Minecraft Wiki article on fire, but it gets pretty wordy and difficult to understand. Is the fireplace pictured below safe?

    View from inside. (The wood planks in the fireplace will be the fuel, and eventually replaced with netherrack): View from inside.

    Up close view. (Fuel has been removed): Up close view.

    Outside view. (4 dirt blocks have been removed to show base of chimney): Outside view

  • I would say no From the Wiki

    More precisely, a fire block can turn any air block into fire that is adjacent to a flammable block and up to one block downwards, one block sideways (including diagonals), and four blocks upwards.

    Also, this answer would suggest not as well.

  • To answer your question, I decided to experiment with your build. I tried to replicate your fireplace as accurately as I could, while limiting the size of the structure surrounding it:

    enter image description here

    I tried to keep the base structure of the fireplace as close to identical as I could.

    enter image description here

    I first attempted the fire with the wood planks shown in your pictures:

    enter image description here

    Unfortunately, the wood burned down to nothing, and the fire eventually died. I then tried it with Netherrack.

    enter image description here

    Everything seemed to be going well. I thought I'd successfully completed the experiment, when suddenly:

    enter image description here

    EVERYTHING QUICKLY WENT HORRIBLY WRONG!!

    The end result to follow:

    enter image description here

    Alas, my structure (house) was destroyed. I feel I didn't even get to know my creation, for it died within minutes of me setting the fire.

    Long story short, NO. The fire will spread to your house.

    five wooden blocks were harmed in the making of this answer

    EDIT It is worth noting, however, that out of the 4 times I've rebuilt/retested, every time the fire has started at the bushes along the outside of the fireplace.

    enter image description here

Tags
minecraft
Related questions and answers
  • Does anyone know what is going on with the smiley faces appearing on sonar vision over certain works of art? I assume it is more than one place but I've only noticed it once so far and that is in a bedroom in the safe house mission very early in the game. I've only been playing an hour or so.

  • I'm having an issue with my house after 1.2 and after researching any changes that may have been made My house is still invalid. It's all made out of stone and I've never had an issue like this before. My houses before 1.2 have been much bigger and much smaller but were always valid Is there a size limit to how large a house can be? I tried adding a row of stone from where the corner torch above the door is to the other side but still said not valid. EDIT: It seems I did reach some size maximum in the previous picture, but the one below shows that its suitable and the guide moved in.

  • Possible Duplicates: Minecraft Nightmares (or, how to not get woken by mobs!) How to construct a safe sleeping area in 1.5 version? I've built a rather large house with a high roof. I put up light everywhere to make it bright enough that a monster won't spawn in the house. When I go to sleep in that house, monsters always spawn. So, I made a 4 square wide room, with only a bed, a door and 2 lights. Door closed, monsters still spawn inside the room! Is that a bug or am I doing something wrong?

  • I recently downloaded a game on the windows 8 app store called "Rule The Kingdom". As you can see in this particular picture, I have a worker named Gregory Oakheart. Every time someone else chops 4 pieces of wood, he only gives me 2 stone. Is this because he specialises in gathering wood from the Mighty Oaks? Thus, his surname, Oakheart, or is it because it is normal for wood to be gathered faster than stone.

  • Background: I built a nice village with NPCs. I have also built a "wall" out of wooden beams and some "towers" at the side ends. After a goblin invasion, we had some casualties, so I decided to remove the houses and build an apartment kind of building. But, I ran into another problem. I built the first floor—it worked fine, but in the second floor, none of the NPCs moved in, and that's the problem. What could be wrong? Any help would be appreciated.

  • What is this object in Make No Wonder? I have built a bridge to one but I can't seem to collect anything from it.

  • I'd like to paint a pixel art mural using the Paint Roller. I would like to use a background with the least amount of texture "noise" so the colors of the pixel art stands out the most. To illustrate, here are several pre-hardmode background tiles painted sky blue: (cactus, dirt, mahogany, bone, mushroom, stone, wood) Based on this limited sample, dirt walls out of everything seem to do alright: However this is not even close to all available walls in the game. Which wall is the most plain and makes colors the most vibrant?

  • What can I blow up? GnomeSlice

    I noticed that there's a particular element in Futuridium that you can break through easily by shooting. It looks like a stack of boxes. It seems you have to break through it in some stages in order to get a good line on power cubes. However, I also noticed just now that you can destroy the automated laser turrets and missile launchers. What elements can I destroy? Is there anything else? Is it safe to assume you can blow up any hostile elements that might appear in later levels?

  • I started playing Candybox 2 and I was really getting into it, it was hard to make things out but I went along with it, then I saw these pictures where the lines where perfectly matched and easy to see detail and I think my view is messed up some how... What others seem to see: What I see: I really wanna play this game, but it is far too hard to see anything...

Data information