Dealing with the dreaded Terran Base Race

Lotus Notes
  • Dealing with the dreaded Terran Base Race Lotus Notes

    In my recent games, I've been having a lot of trouble with Terrans who refuse to engage my army even if it arrives knocking on their doorstep (I play Protoss mostly), because they know that they will always win in a base race. If I arrive at their base and start killing their workers and buildings, they simply go to my base and do the same.

    This usually happens around the early-mid push so both players have mostly tier 1, maybe a couple tier 2 units out, but it's even easier once they have Medivacs because they can fly out of their base unharmed and land in mine.

    What I've noticed is that there is far less risk for them leaving their base unattended. Why?

    • They can simply lift off a lot of their buildings which can't be killed fast enough by stalkers, since I also need an approximately equal number of zealots to survive tier 1.
    • Even if I kill all their workers, then leave to return and defend what's left of my base, they can recover from the economic loss quite well with MULEs.
    • Terran t1 units tend to do kill buildings faster anyway.
    • Killing Pylons cripples the Protoss player much more than killing Supply Depots hurts the Terran. I end up being supply blocked and my warp gates have no power so I can't produce anything, while he can still make at least a few things from his barracks.

    Options I've tried:

    • Leaving 2 or 3 sentries at my choke to slow them down. If I look away for even a second, the Terran player has already stimmed and taken out the sentries before I can block them off with force fields.
    • Taking out their workers and the command center, then heading back to my base. All my Pylons and workers are already dead and he's probably had enough time to kill my Nexus, so game over, as he can still produce a few marines at least while all my warp gates are unpowered and I am supply blocked.
    • Leaving behind a portion of my army. It's too difficult to split up the army, because my offensive force won't kill his base fast enough and my defensive one isn't big enough to defend from his force.
    • Letting my base die, continuing to kill his and chase his flying buildings around the map while attempting to 'Farm-hide' Pylons or Nexuses until I kill all of his buildings, or possibly engage his army and hope to win. I usually end up losing when I try this as he's still been able to produce several more units from hidden barrackses while my warp gates are unpowered.
    • On ledge and cliff oriented maps, like Desert Oasis where the Terran likes to use drop ships a lot, going Stargate first instead of Robo and trying to gain air superiority. The terran just uses their superior ground army to beat mine, and leaves behind a few marines in their base to deal with the Protoss air units.
    • Sitting in my base, never leaving it until I have at least a couple Colossi with the range upgrade. Okay, this works most of the time but a two-way turtle-tech-fest is really boring.

    It is true that I do play mostly against my buddies and that they have a higher probability of opting for a base race than in your average 1v1 quick match vs. unknown opponents (although in Diamond league I've faced a lot of people who do this as well). But I want to know if there's anything I can do to prevent every single P vs. T game from turning into this.

  • It sounds like you're building a large army and using it to gain map control, but then are falling prey to things like drops and backdooring.

    If you have map control your first thought should never be: Crush my opponent, as you're essentially sacrificing an advantage (map control) for an unsure victory (because he doesn't control the map doesn't mean he can't take you). Instead your thought should be: take the map. I think you'll find this change in philosophy will lead to situations where you have a much more powerful economy than him and you're able to kill him with attrition.

    Now if you're falling prey to things like BD here is a quick check list for you:

    • Are you scouting? an Observer should be the first thing you build out of Robo. If you don't go Robo, a Hallucination works just as well. Sometimes scouting means sacrificing some Zealots in a pointless charge to just get inside his base.
    • If you're scouting, are you seeing it coming? Overlords on the edge of your base, Starport with Reactor + 3 Rax, all of these are indicative of certain strategies you should watch out for.
    • If you see it coming, how are you responding? If you have map control that means you should be able to respond quickly. Shutting down these back door attempts is often a bigger victory than a straight up conflict
    • Finally, Do you have map control? If you don't have map control that means he does, and if he's beating you with map control then your problem is not "how do I deal with a base trade?" but rather, how do I regain the advantage.

  • Scouting is key. Knowing what your opponent has and what he is doing with it is crucial to victory. I would focus on dealing with his main army. If you can keep them bottled up in their base, many players go air. If you know that their main force left their base, try to slip a few zealots in to kill workers. Use your main force to kill their force. If you have enough for Templars and Psi Storm, they work well with weakening marines.

    The key here, like @tzenes said, is map control. Fighting through a natural choke point is a terrible way to go. Try to take on the terrans out in the open or by a cliff that you can station your Stalkers on. As long as you can take out their air units, you can use your zealots to hold them on the "killing field" without loosing your ranged attacks.

    I sometimes station a random pylon with two cannons near the base, but out of the way to warp in a few units to attack when the main force leaves. They can either turn back, or split their forces to deal with that small force. It can be tough to micro that, but you'd be surprised what a few zealots can do when no one is looking. If you can get them to look away from the main fight, it would be worth it.

    Hope this helps

starcraft-2 protoss terran
Related questions and answers
  • run away. If not, it could absorb enough of their fire to buy us more time than a force field. Turtle. My ally and I prefer longer games so we just want to be able to hold off rushes. So should we do...+roach attack on Monlyth Ridge. We scouted and knew it was coming, but I don't know what we could have done to stop it. They killed my pylons while I tried to hold them off, thus I couldn't reinforce... in the game, but against decent opponents at about 6-8 minutes, this isn't very powerful / possible because: I have very few units to distract them with. My map coverage & economy is not enough

  • dropped the widow mine behind his second and killed all his workers (it took him a long time to take out the widow mine and I even was able to kill a queen with it, so I dont think he noticed till...Alright, so my favorite build against zerg is the 1 Base, Battlecruiser Build. This build has proved to be 100% effective against zerg, the only time I usually struggle is against randoms who end up... easily. At this point I have a very sizeable force of hellions and marines and a battlecruiser which I push out with, wrecking his small force of roaches and what was left of his natural expansion. He

  • overrun by tanks. Rush the Forge player with full out Warthogs and Hunters - this fails because the 2 Arbiters have enough time to individually blow up all your bases while you are trying to fight forge.... (6) if the person who got attacked first has turret(s) up, they can usually weaken or kill a couple of grunts before they hit the base, requiring more grunts to hit the base before it gets blown up...I have been playing halo wars since the game came out(forever ago). Only recently, the last few months, has this strategy emerged. Me and my friends have lost around 50 games to this rush. We have

  • fucking serious and in the last few waves you just have to spam cannonballs (it's still more fun than your run of the mill 16 player coop where you're trying to engage some enemies that you can kill..., even if he had 60% to start with. They're just scripted that way. You have a little more time to strike this time around, and I got him to 1% at best. Then he resumes regenerating and I'm back... with over one million points (you lose 10k on death), then Ugh-Zan arrived. Well, my use-one-bar-then-spam-cannons strategy didn't work so well, perhaps unsurprisingly. So I kept throwing bars at his

  • I think I can master the early game pretty well now in Marine Arena, but I get into trouble in the endgame. Often I engage the enemy with my army, and we both lose most of our troops. Suddenly I have a lot of resources from the battle (1500 - 2000), but almost no units, except the ones that recently spawned. Now the enemy can just come into my base and crush me (the one I just fought with a couple of their leftover units, or worse, a third enemy). Upgrading units in the short term seems a waste as I have so few. Buying a hero takes too long (and I also might not have hero upgrades yet

  • Vikings, marines, medivacs, some banshees, and had time to save all my SCVs. He lost whole army, but I saved 5-6 vikings, few banshees. So it was more or less good for me. The end. Still, I had few... him hellion drop and killed around 15 drones; mutas killed my medivacs in the end of drop. Middle game: I made 2nd expansion, zerg did 2 more. I denied his 1 and killed drones on the 2nd exp (so he... will be able to build enough and proper army in time... But: Question 1: how can you know what kind of army expect from Zerg (if he has all 3: ban.nest, roach warren, spire)? Possible answer: Just

  • with the same rate as minerals). Plus 100 for bunker - 327 minerals So I will be able to have 4 barracks against his 1 barrack + 1 factory. In the same time. Each 50 seconds: - I will produce 8 marines; - he will produce 2 marines + 1 tank. Till the time he research "siege mode" (80 seconds) I will have around 13 marines, he will have 2 tanks + 4 marines (been sitting in bunker, having SCV repairing...Playing Terran in my previous league I've beat a lot of other Terrans with Mega Rax strategy. In my implementation it looks like this: 10 Supply 11 Barrack 12 Refinery 14(or15) Barrack 2 in mean

  • , but it seems challenging my heir is not a justified reason to do so. Nor can I revoke his title. As I see it, I have a few options: Give control of more powerful counties to my heir, thus making... on. Now, seeing as the land I had given him was useless anyway, I gave him a better one. Still not enough to win the war, but at least he'd still have a title while I plotted revenge. Coincidentally, my... to rebel against me, so I could have his head cut off, and tried numerous things, such as making him a court jester and bad mouthing him. Finally, I raised all his units (only a couple of hundred

  • point in doing anything with this time other than just completing the basic mission? Otherwise, it seems like the scene may as well have been done as just a non-interactive cut-scene. I understand..., but would like to know ahead of time whether or not there will be any point to it. This is primarily because I have horrible saving habits (or, rather, a lack thereof) and so I do not have an easy way... mean certain doom for Joker and/or the Normandy. Besides this, players who have been paying attention won't want to over-exert him anyway due to his bone condition. So, during my first (and so far

Data information